Delimitation Commission of India | UPSC POLITY NOTES

Delimitation means fixing or drawing the boundaries of electoral constituencies. It is the process of dividing a country or state into election area

 

Delimitation Commission of India

Delimitation Commission of India — ಭಾರತದ ಕ್ಷೇತ್ರ ಗಡಿ ನಿರ್ಧಾರ ಆಯೋಗ / ಭಾರತದ ಕ್ಷೇತ್ರ ಮರುಸೀಮಾ ಆಯೋಗ

Meaning of Delimitation

  • Delimitation means fixing or drawing the boundaries of electoral constituencies.

  • These constituencies are territorial areas from which representatives are elected to legislative bodies.

Simple Meaning:
It is the process of dividing a country or state into election areas (constituencies).

Example

  • Suppose a state has 1 crore population.

  • It may be divided into 20 constituencies.

  • Each constituency elects one representative to the Assembly or Parliament.

  • The process of drawing these boundaries is called delimitation.

Body Responsible

  • The task of delimitation is given to a special high-powered body.

  • This body is called the Delimitation Commission or Boundary Commission.


Rationale (Importance) of Delimitation

1. Ensures Free and Fair Elections

  • Free and fair elections are the hallmark of democracy.

  • Parliamentary democracy works because people choose their representatives through elections.

  • Elections are therefore essential for democracy.

  • For elections to be fair, constituencies must be properly defined.

  • The delimitation process periodically redraws electoral boundaries.

  • This is done according to legal provisions and accepted norms.

  • Because India follows a system of single-member constituencies (one representative per constituency), delimitation becomes very important.

Example

  • If a constituency becomes too large in population, voters will not be equally represented.

  • Delimitation reorganizes boundaries to maintain fairness.


2. Reflects Changing Ground Reality

  • Delimitation is a complex and sensitive process.

  • It forms the foundation of democratic representation through elections.

  • In theory, delimitation helps create a political system where people govern themselves through elected representatives based on territory.

  • Since population and settlement patterns change over time, constituencies must be redrawn periodically.

Example

  • A city may grow from 5 lakh population to 25 lakh population.

  • Without delimitation, the same constituency may represent too many people.

  • Therefore periodic delimitation adjusts constituencies according to new realities.


3. Principle of “One Man, One Vote”

  • Democracy follows the principle of one person, one vote.

  • Ideally, the value of each vote should be equal.

  • In practice, this is difficult to achieve perfectly.

  • Sometimes two constituencies elect one representative each, but their populations differ.

  • If one constituency has less population, the vote of each voter becomes more powerful than in a constituency with more population.

Example

  • Constituency A → 1 lakh voters

  • Constituency B → 3 lakh voters

Both elect one MP.

  • In Constituency A → 1 vote represents fewer people → vote value is higher

  • In Constituency B → 1 vote represents more people → vote value is lower

This issue was observed by the Supreme Court in the case

  • R. C. Poudyal v. Union of India


Delimitation Commissions Established So Far

  • The Delimitation Commission of India is a statutory body.

  • It is not a constitutional body.

Meaning

  • It is created through a law passed by Parliament, not directly by the Constitution.

  • The Central Government establishes it under a law enacted by Parliament.

Main Function

  • To determine and redraw the boundaries of

    • Parliamentary constituencies (Lok Sabha)

    • State Assembly constituencies

Powers of the Commission

  • It is a very powerful body.

Its orders:

  • Have the force of law

  • Cannot be challenged in any court

After the Commission finalizes its orders:

  • They come into effect on a date specified by the President of India.

  • They are placed before the Lok Sabha and State Legislative Assemblies.

However:

  • These bodies cannot modify the orders.

Number of Commissions

  • So far four Delimitation Commissions have been constituted in India.


Constitutional Provisions Related to Delimitation

The following Articles deal with delimitation of constituencies:

  • Article 81

  • Article 82

  • Article 170

  • Article 330

  • Article 332

These Articles were amended by:

  • 84th Constitutional Amendment Act

  • 87th Constitutional Amendment Act

Combined Effect of These Amendments

1. Lok Sabha Seats Frozen

  • The number of seats allotted to states in the Lok Sabha based on the 1971 Census will remain unchanged.

  • This freeze will continue until the first census after 2026.

2. State Assembly Seats Frozen

  • The number of seats in State Legislative Assemblies fixed using the 1971 Census will also remain unchanged until the census after 2026.

Example

  • If a state had 200 Assembly seats based on the 1971 census, the number cannot be increased or reduced until after 2026.

3. Reservation for SC and ST Recalculated

  • The number of reserved seats for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in:

    • Lok Sabha

    • State Legislative Assemblies

  • These are recalculated using the 2001 Census.

4. Redelimitation Based on 2001 Census

  • Every state was redelimited into parliamentary and assembly constituencies using the 2001 Census.

  • The boundaries created during this delimitation will remain frozen until the first census after 2026.

5. Population Equality Among Constituencies

  • While redrawing boundaries, the population of each constituency should be nearly equal across the state, as far as possible.

Example

  • If a state constituency average population is 2 lakh, then constituencies should be close to 2 lakh population to maintain equal representation.


Delimitation in Jammu & Kashmir (Simple Explanation)

1. Why Delimitation in J&K Was Different Earlier

Earlier, Jammu & Kashmir had special constitutional status.

This special status existed because of Article 370.

Because of this:

  • Many Indian constitutional rules did not fully apply to J&K.

  • J&K had its own Constitution and laws.

But this special status ended in 2019 after:

  • Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019


2. Two Different Laws Controlled Delimitation Earlier

Before 2019, delimitation in J&K worked in two different ways.

Lok Sabha Seats

  • Controlled by the Constitution of India.

State Assembly Seats

  • Controlled by:

    • Constitution of J&K

    • Jammu and Kashmir Representation of the People Act, 1957

Meaning

  • Parliamentary constituencies → decided by Indian law

  • Assembly constituencies → decided by J&K state law

This was different from other states of India.


3. Earlier Delimitation Exercises in J&K

Assembly constituencies were redrawn in:

  • 1957

  • 1966

  • 1975

  • 1995

The last delimitation (1995) used the 1981 Census.

That delimitation was used for the 1996 J&K elections.


4. Why Delimitation Did Not Happen After 1995

Two reasons:

Reason 1: No Census in 1991

Because of security issues and insurgency, census was not conducted in J&K in 1991.

Reason 2: Freeze on Delimitation

The J&K Legislative Assembly passed a law.

This law said:

  • No new delimitation until the census after 2026.

So the constituencies remained the same for many years.


5. Structure of the J&K Assembly Before 2019

The J&K Assembly had 111 seats.

Breakdown:

  • 87 seats filled through elections, Including 4 seats from Ladakh

  • 24 seats kept vacant

Why 24 Seats Were Vacant

These seats were reserved for areas under Pakistan’s control (PoJK).

India considers these areas part of J&K, but elections cannot be held there.

So those 24 seats remain vacant.


6. Changes After 2019 Reorganisation

Major change happened through:

  • Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019

This Act:

  • Abolished the old state

  • Created Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir


7. New Structure of the Assembly

The new Assembly has:

  • 114 total seats

But:

  • 24 seats remain vacant for PoJK

So 90 seats are actually filled through elections.


8. Nomination of Women Members

The law also says:

The Lieutenant Governor can nominate 2 women members if women are not adequately represented in the Assembly.


9. Increase in Assembly Seats

Earlier elected seats = 83

Now elected seats = 90

So there is an increase of 7 seats.


10. Why New Delimitation Was Needed

The last delimitation used 1981 Census data.

But by 2011 Census, the population had increased more than 100%.

Example:

CensusPopulation
1981smaller
2011more than double

Because constituencies were based on old population, many seats became unequal.

This situation is called malapportionment.

Meaning of Malapportionment

Some constituencies have too many people, others too few people.

Example:

ConstituencyPopulation
A1 lakh
B4 lakh

Both elect one MLA.

So voters in A have more political power.

This is unfair.

So delimitation was necessary.


11. New Delimitation Based on 2011 Census

The new Delimitation Commission used:

  • 2011 Census population

  • Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019

  • Delimitation Act, 2002


12. Reservation of Seats

Seat reservation for SC and ST was calculated using:

  • Article 330

  • Article 332

These articles deal with reservation of seats for SCs and STs in legislatures.


13. Important Change Regarding ST Reservation

Earlier:

  • The J&K Constitution did not provide reservation for STs in the Assembly.

After delimitation:

  • ST seats were reserved for the first time in the J&K Assembly.


Super Simple Summary (UPSC Revision)

  • J&K had special status under Article 370, so delimitation rules were different.

  • Lok Sabha seats followed Indian Constitution, but Assembly seats followed J&K laws.

  • Delimitation occurred in 1957, 1966, 1975, 1995.

  • Last delimitation used 1981 Census.

  • J&K Assembly froze delimitation until census after 2026.

  • Assembly earlier had 111 seats (24 reserved for PoJK).

  • After J&K Reorganisation Act 2019, UT of J&K created.

  • New Assembly → 114 seats (90 elected + 24 PoJK vacant).

  • New delimitation used 2011 Census.

  • ST reservation introduced for the first time.


Order of the Delimitation Commission (Jammu & Kashmir – 2022)

In May 2022, the Delimitation Commission issued the final order for redrawing:

  • Lok Sabha constituencies

  • Assembly constituencies

in the Union Territory of J&K.

This was done under the:

  • Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019

  • Delimitation Act, 2002


1. J&K Treated as One Single Unit

The Commission considered entire J&K as one entity while delimiting parliamentary constituencies.

Result

J&K has 5 Lok Sabha constituencies.

Each Lok Sabha constituency now contains 18 Assembly segments.

Example

Lok Sabha seatAssembly segments
Seat 118 Assembly seats
Seat 218 Assembly seats
Seat 318 Assembly seats
Seat 418 Assembly seats
Seat 518 Assembly seats

Total:

5 × 18 = 90 Assembly constituencies


2. Creation of Anantnag–Rajouri Parliamentary Seat

A new Lok Sabha constituency was created.

Name:

Anantnag–Rajouri

This constituency combines areas from two different regions:

AreaRegion
AnantnagKashmir region
Rajouri & PoonchJammu region

Simple Meaning

Earlier, parliamentary constituencies were mostly within the same region.

Now one constituency includes areas from both Jammu and Kashmir regions.


3. Distribution of Assembly Seats

Total Assembly constituencies in J&K = 90

They are divided as:

RegionSeats
Jammu43
Kashmir47

So Kashmir has 4 more seats than Jammu.


4. Creation of New Assembly Constituencies

The Commission increased the number of seats.

New seats created:

RegionNew seats
Jammu6
Kashmir1

Total new seats = 7

This is why total elected seats became 90.


5. Reservation for Scheduled Tribes (ST)

The Commission reserved 9 Assembly constituencies for Scheduled Tribes (ST).

Distribution:

RegionST seats
Jammu6
Kashmir3

Important Point

This was the first time ST seats were reserved in the J&K Assembly.

Earlier, under the old J&K Constitution, ST reservation did not exist.


6. Reservation for Scheduled Castes (SC)

The Commission reserved 7 Assembly constituencies for Scheduled Castes (SC).

These reservations were done based on:

  • Article 330

  • Article 332

These articles provide reservation for SCs and STs in legislatures.


7. Change in Names of Constituencies

The Commission also changed the names of some Assembly constituencies.

Example:

One constituency was named:

Shri Mata Vaishno Devi

This is a famous religious area in Jammu.


Recommendations of the Commission

During the delimitation process, the Commission conducted public hearings.

Two important groups made requests:

  1. Kashmiri migrants

  2. People displaced from Pakistan-occupied J&K (PoJK)

These groups requested political representation.


1. Recommendation for Kashmiri Migrants

Many Kashmiri Pandits and other migrants had left Kashmir due to militancy.

They argued:

  • They were forced to leave their homes

  • They have lived as refugees in their own country for 30 years

They asked for political representation.

Commission Recommendation

At least 2 members should represent Kashmiri migrants in the J&K Assembly.

Conditions:

  • One member must be a woman

These members should have powers similar to nominated members in the Puducherry Assembly.


2. Recommendation for PoJK Displaced Persons

People displaced from Pakistan-occupied Jammu & Kashmir during:

  • 1947–48 war

  • 1965 war

  • 1971 war

also demanded representation.

Commission Recommendation

The Central Government may nominate representatives of these displaced persons to the J&K Assembly.

This would ensure their political representation.


Ultra-Simple UPSC Revision (5 Lines)

  • 2022 Delimitation created 90 Assembly constituencies in J&K.

  • Distribution → 43 Jammu, 47 Kashmir.

  • 7 new seats added (6 Jammu + 1 Kashmir).

  • 9 ST seats and 7 SC seats reserved.

  • New Anantnag–Rajouri Lok Sabha constituency created.



Post a Comment