Home
Polity-Mains-PYQ

Discuss each adjective attached to the word ‘Republic’ in the ‘Preamble’. Are they defendable in the present circumstances? UPSC Mains 2016

Amith

Preamble

✅ Question (GS Paper II – 2016):

“Discuss each adjective attached to the word ‘Republic’ in the ‘Preamble’. Are they defendable in the present circumstances?”

1. Keyword-Based Analysis

  • Directive Words:

    • Discuss: Requires description of each adjective logically and with explanation.

    • Are they defendable?: Needs critical evaluation in the present context—not just descriptive.

  • Key Concepts:

    • Preamble

    • Adjectives attached to 'Republic'

    • Constitutional values vs ground realities

2. Demand of the Question

You are expected to:

  • Identify and explain each adjective (Sovereign, Socialist, Secular, Democratic)

  • Show how these adjectives are connected to the concept of a Republic

  • Evaluate whether these ideals are upheld or being challenged today

  • Maintain a balanced and evidence-based analysis

3. Ideal Structure of the Answer

Introduction

  • Quote or briefly explain the Preamble as the soul of the Constitution.

  • Define the term Republic and how adjectives describe its character.

Body

A. Adjectives in the Preamble linked to Republic

  1. Sovereign

    • Meaning: India is free from external control and has internal supremacy.

    • Defendable?

      • ✅ Yes – we make independent foreign policy decisions (e.g., non-alignment, strategic autonomy in Ukraine-Russia war)

      • ❌ Concerns over trade dependency, cyber sovereignty

  2. Socialist

    • Meaning: Commitment to reducing economic inequality; mixed economy model.

    • Defendable?

      • ✅ Welfare schemes like MGNREGA, PMGKAY, PMAY

      • ❌ Rising income disparity, corporate monopolies

  3. Secular

    • Meaning: Equal treatment of all religions by the State.

    • Defendable?

      • ✅ Legal safeguards (Articles 25–28), SC verdicts (e.g., Sabarimala)

      • ❌ Rising communal tensions, misuse of hate speech, politicization of religion

  4. Democratic

    • Meaning: Popular sovereignty, periodic elections, rule of law

    • Defendable?

      • ✅ Regular elections, active judiciary, RTI, PILs

      • ❌ Electoral funding opacity, anti-defection misuse, weakening debate in Parliament

Conclusion

  • Reaffirm faith in constitutional ideals.

  • While challenges exist, these adjectives remain guiding lights for India's democratic journey.

4. Model Answer (250 Words)

The Preamble of the Indian Constitution encapsulates the philosophy and aspirations of the nation. As a Republic, India rests on foundational adjectives—Sovereign, Socialist, Secular, Democratic—each defining its identity and duties.

A Sovereign India exercises absolute authority over its territory and decisions. It is defendable through independent foreign policy moves such as the balanced stance in the Russia–Ukraine war. However, issues like cyber dependency and trade-linked constraints question our full economic sovereignty.

The term Socialist, introduced via the 42nd Amendment, implies economic equity and social justice. It finds expression in welfare initiatives like MGNREGA, National Food Security Act, and Ayushman Bharat. Yet, wealth concentration, rising inequality, and jobless growth challenge this ideal.

Secularism, as practiced in India, means equal respect for all religions. Despite constitutional protections (Articles 25–28) and judicial activism, increasing communal polarization, politicization of religion, and intolerance threaten its fabric.

The adjective Democratic assures political equality, universal suffrage, and rule of law. India regularly conducts elections, and mechanisms like RTI and PILs empower citizens. Nonetheless, decreasing parliamentary productivity, criminalization of politics, and electoral funding opacity dilute democratic vibrancy.

In conclusion, these adjectives are still constitutionally and morally defendable, though not free from contemporary stress. Their implementation is evolving, and the true test lies in constant public and institutional vigilance to uphold them.

5. Value Addition Tips

  • Diagram:
    A mind map with "Republic" at center and arrows to adjectives + challenges

  • Quotes:

    • "The Preamble is the identity card of the Constitution" – N.A. Palkhivala

    • "India is a sovereign socialist secular democratic republic." – Preamble

  • Examples:

    • Secular: Hijab controversy (Karnataka), Triple Talaq judgment

    • Democratic: 2024 General Elections, record voter turnout

    • Socialist: Digital India + DBT schemes

  • Constitutional Articles:

    • Sovereign: Art 1 (Union of States), Art 51 (foreign policy)

    • Socialist: DPSPs (Art 39b, 39c)

    • Secular: Arts 25–28

    • Democratic: Art 326 (elections), Art 19 (freedom)

6. Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Writing generic definitions without linking to ‘Republic’

  • Ignoring the present-day context (misses critical part of question)

  • Failing to evaluate both positive and negative aspects (no balance)

  • Missing constitutional references or relevant examples

Post a Comment